How do SEO agencies measure success and what results should we expect?

SVZ measures success using a combination of key metrics that reflect improvements in your online visibility and business outcomes. Here are the main ones:

• Keyword Rankings: Tracking the positions of your target keywords in search engine results pages (SERPs) is a basic metric. For example, if you start at #50 and now you’re #5, that’s clear progress. However, ranking increases alone aren’t the end goal – they are a means to an end (more traffic).
• Organic Traffic: The amount of traffic coming to your site from search engines (excluding paid ads) is a fundamental measure. If your organic sessions per month are growing, especially for the pages that have been optimized or created, that’s a positive sign. Agencies will often compare month-over-month and year-over-year organic traffic.
• Organic Conversions: This is arguably the most important. It’s great to get traffic, but are those visitors doing what you want (buying a product, filling a lead form, subscribing)? A good SEO agency ties their efforts to conversion metrics – e.g., “organic leads increased from 20 to 40 per month” or “organic sales revenue grew 30%”. This connects SEO to ROI.
• Quality of Traffic: An advanced agency will also look at engagement metrics from organic visitors – bounce rate, time on site, pages per visit – to ensure the traffic coming is relevant. If you get a ton of traffic that immediately bounces, those rankings might not be truly valuable. Ideally, SEO efforts bring qualified traffic that engages and converts.
• Backlink Profile Improvements: Since link-building is part of SEO, agencies track the growth in the number and quality of backlinks to your site (using tools like Moz, Ahrefs, etc.). If you acquired 20 new links from reputable sites over a quarter, that’s a measurable achievement that will likely boost your authority.
• Technical Improvements: Post-technical SEO work, they might measure things like site speed (e.g., “page load time improved from 4s to 2s”) or crawl errors fixed (e.g., “reduced 404 errors by 100%”). While not directly visible to business owners, these support the other metrics and agencies will report them to show comprehensive progress.
• Local SEO metrics (if relevant): For example, growth in Google Maps impressions or calls/directions from your Google My Business listing if local business is a focus.

In terms of results to expect: by month ~6, you should see noticeable improvements in many of these metrics – higher rankings for a set of keywords, an upward trend in organic visitors, and ideally some increase in leads/sales attributable to SEO. By 12 months, the goal is often to have multiple Page 1 rankings and a significant percentage of your site’s traffic coming from organic search.

A stat from earlier: top agencies measure success in both qualitative and quantitative ways, aligning with the client’s business goals. That means they’ll discuss things like brand visibility and customer engagement, not just raw traffic.
‍

A concrete example: If you run an e-commerce, a result could be “We improved your ranking for 15 high-intent product keywords from page 3 to page 1, leading to a 25% increase in organic sales this quarter versus last.”

Or for a B2B service, “Organic traffic is up 60% year-over-year and those visitors spend 40% longer on the site than before, resulting in twice as many demo requests from organic.”

These are the kinds of successes an SEO agency should aim for and report.

SVZ does set up dashboard reports so you can monitor these KPIs anytime in a custom view - made for each role on your team.

At SVZ, we ensure our clients have clarity on how we’re tracking against targets.

We define success collaboratively – for one client it might be more traffic, for another it’s specific conversions – and then we show progress regularly.

We believe in accountability: if something we tried didn’t move the needle, we’ll tell you and pivot.

But overall, if the SEO strategy is solid, within 6-12 months you should see tangible, positive movement on all the metrics mentioned, indicating that your investment is paying off in increased visibility and business growth.

‍